An international team says a 115-million-year-old dinosaur bone from Brazil contains traces of the oldest mineralized red blood cells ever found. Outside experts aren't convinced the microscopic structures are cells at all. The awkward alternative: minerals doing a very good impression. Source
The study, published in Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences, was led by Curtin University organic geochemist Kliti Grice. According to Science's reporting, her team's case combines the structures' shape, their location inside the bone and chemical evidence associated with blood. Grice isn't claiming pristine cells survived unchanged for 115 million years. The proposed discovery is mineralized remains containing heme-derived molecules. Source
Inside the bone
The researchers examined bone from Aratasaurus museunacionali. Inside channels that once carried blood vessels, they found rounded structures with sunken centers, averaging 23 microns long and almost 20 microns wide. Blood cells usually break down soon after death, and minerals can mimic their shape, so a convincing silhouette wasn't going to settle this. Source
The team didn't just spot a blob and call it a day. Science reports that the researchers performed almost 30 tests. Laser analysis of ground bone samples reportedly detected heme, an iron-containing compound that helps red blood cells transport oxygen. They also found larger amounts of degraded heme, which Grice interprets as consistent with an ancient origin. Source
Contamination was a major concern. The microbial mat surrounding the fossil contains chlorophyll, which is chemically similar to heme. In that mat, chlorophyll-related molecules outnumbered heme by more than 300 to one; in the bone, heme-related molecules dominated. Source
X-rays and electron microscopy also associated the structures with a type of manganese oxide. The authors suspect that mineral helped preserve them. Source
Heme isn't a cell ID
Field Museum paleontologist Evan Saitta, who wasn't involved in the study, told Science he is convinced heme is present. His objection concerns the structures: they could be manganese oxide blobs rather than cells. Source
Mary Schweitzer, a North Carolina State University paleontologist also uninvolved in the work, raised another problem. The structures are larger than red blood cells in birds and crocodiles, nonavian dinosaurs' closest living relatives, and show no sign of the nuclei those animals' red blood cells contain. She told Science she remains unconvinced they are red blood cells. Source
Grice stands by the combined evidence. “The shape, location, and chemistry supports these being mineralized dinosaur red blood cells,” she told Science. Source
Identifying dinosaur blood cells could help researchers understand how the animals adapted to their environments, Schweitzer told Science. Source
University College Cork paleobiologist Maria McNamara called the work “probably the most comprehensive effort that's been done so far,” while urging caution about the cell identification. She wants more tests to exclude other sources of heme or similar chemicals, and experimental replication of the proposed fossilization process. Source
Comments