Mercuria’s challenge to a Baltic Exchange tanker-rate benchmark reached a London trial on Oct. 26, Bloomberg reported. The commodity trader argues that the Baltic should have suspended the rate after the conflict involving the U.S., Israel and Iran disrupted exports through the Strait of Hormuz. The Baltic contests the claim and denies breaching its duties as a benchmark administrator, according to Bloomberg.
The dispute centers on TD3C, which tracks the daily cost of transporting 270,000 metric tons of crude oil from the Middle East Gulf to China, according to the Financial Times. The exchange’s rates are used by commodity traders to price derivatives worth billions of dollars that hedge their risks. Maritime London chief executive Mark Williams told the FT that the indices are not an “actual price” but reflect what brokers think the rate would be on a given day.
According to the FT’s account of Mercuria’s claim, the trader wants a declaration requiring the Baltic to suspend TD3C and invalidate publications of the rate since early March. Mercuria is not seeking damages; the FT reports that it removed references to financial losses from an amended claim. Bloomberg reports Mercuria also accused the Baltic of continuing to publish the rate because it feared losing business to a competitor.
The Baltic said in its defence that some oil-carrying ships still passed through Hormuz and that shipbrokers continued to provide rates, the FT reported. Baltic chief executive Mark Jackson told the FT the exchange was confident it had met its obligations and believed Mercuria’s claim was without merit.
The Baltic’s lawyers warned that a Mercuria victory would have “chaotic marketwide consequences,” according to the FT. People close to the Baltic told the paper that hundreds of trades might have to be unwound. Philippe van den Abeele, founder of Consortium Maritime Trading, told the FT the Baltic was “behind the curve” on geopolitical tanker disruptions and should not produce prices for trades in a war zone. One unnamed shipbroker called the dispute “a mess” but said Mercuria “might have a point,” despite being on the wrong side of some trades.
Comments