UniCredit has won unconditional European Commission competition clearance and US Federal Reserve approval for its proposed €45 billion takeover of Germany’s Commerzbank, Reuters reported on November 16. The decisions follow European Central Bank approval in October. Source
Brussels has said yes. Berlin still has a list. The German government is seeking job guarantees, retention of Commerzbank’s Frankfurt headquarters and the right to appoint two supervisory-board members, according to POLITICO. UniCredit CEO Andrea Orcel has resisted those demands. Source
EU competition chief Teresa Ribera also delivered a warning: Brussels would defend its decision if a national government tried to prevent the takeover. In that event, “we would react accordingly,” she told reporters, according to POLITICO. Source
Why Brussels said yes
UniCredit already operates in Germany through HypoVereinsbank, whose business overlaps with Commerzbank’s across essentially all retail and corporate banking services. The Commission nevertheless concluded that the proposed combination would raise no competition concerns, according to its release republished by Mirage News. Source
The Commission found the banks’ combined German market shares were moderate except in trade finance, where both have strong positions in instruments such as letters of credit and guarantees. Even there, it concluded that customers would retain alternative providers, including private, public-sector, cooperative and international banks. Source
The Commission took a particularly close look at lending to Germany’s mid-sized companies, the Mittelstand. Its verdict there, too: enough credible rivals would remain to keep the combined bank under competitive pressure. Source
Ribera argued that cross-border mergers could make European banks more efficient and resilient, Reuters reported. “But growth must not come at the expense of customers,” she said. Source
Berlin’s influence is more than political
Germany still owns 13% of Commerzbank, according to POLITICO. Chancellor Friedrich Merz has said he would not stand in the way of the takeover while continuing to object to UniCredit’s approach. Not blocking a deal and embracing it are evidently different propositions. Source
Commerzbank CEO Bettina Orlopp called the EU decision “no surprise,” Reuters reported. UniCredit welcomed the Fed approval, while the German government declined to comment on the EU clearance. Source
Orcel has said he would call a Commerzbank shareholder vote to appoint a new supervisory board immediately after gaining control, according to POLITICO. Source
Comments