A federal judge in Chicago rejected McDonald’s request to dismiss a proposed consumer class action over the McRib on Oct. 30, though she dismissed some claims, Reuters’ Jonathan Stempel reported.
The plaintiffs allege McDonald’s intentionally shaped McRib patties with ridges resembling pork ribs, leading diners to expect rib meat. They also allege that the use of lower-grade pork products, including shoulder, heart, tripe or stomach, caused them to overpay. Those ingredient claims are allegations, not findings.
U.S. District Judge April Perry called it premature to accept McDonald’s argument that no reasonable buyer could expect rib meat. She noted that the company’s website describes the sandwich only as containing pork and said buyers need not research a $7 fast-food sandwich before purchasing it. “Plaintiffs’ proffered understanding of ‘McRib’ is not unreasonable or fanciful,” Perry wrote, according to Reuters. She said ads emphasizing the rib-like shape could support a claim of intent to defraud, but further proof was needed.
McDonald’s argued that distinctive product names do not mislead reasonable consumers and that a preference for a particular cut of pork does not make its marketing fraudulent. In a statement reported by Reuters, the company maintained that it does not use hearts, tripe or stomach in the McRib, said it has been transparent about its ingredients and called the claims meritless. The ruling leaves parts of the lawsuit in place; it does not establish that McDonald’s deceived buyers.
Comments