A Canadian advocacy group says it has identified Forter, a fraud-prevention firm founded by veterans of Israel’s Unit 8200 intelligence division, as a recipient of data collected through the Tim Hortons app. Canadians for Justice and Peace in the Middle East (CJPME) is urging the coffee chain to cut ties with the company. Source
Tim Hortons says the collection serves fraud prevention, account protection and payment abuse prevention—not advertising or marketing. It also told CBC that the third party is prohibited from selling the data and that Tim Hortons does not sell users’ personal information. Source Source
The allegations follow a CBC investigation published November 13. CJPME said it established the recipient’s identity by contacting University of Calgary computer science researcher Joel Reardon, whose findings informed that investigation. CBC did not name the recipient, according to Al Jazeera and Anadolu Agency’s report in Dawn. Source Source
Even ringtone names were on the list
Al Jazeera reported that the research found the app began transmitting information to an overseas third party as soon as it opened. The information included unique device identifiers, camera specifications, sensor lists, the names of ringtones and alarm sounds, and nearby Wi-Fi router names. Source
Quite an inventory for a coffee app.
Researchers said the information could create a digital fingerprint of a device, allowing it to be recognized later. Reardon told CJPME that nearby router names could be used to determine a user’s location. The reports do not show that Forter used those details to track users’ locations. Source Source
Independent analyst Celeste Rollason told CBC the amount collected “seems quite excessive” for purchasing a cup of coffee, Middle East Eye reported. Source
Forter’s founders
Al Jazeera reports that Forter’s founders, Michael Reitblat, Liron Damri and Alon Shemesh, are alumni of Unit 8200, Israel’s signals intelligence and cyberwarfare division. Source
CJPME vice president Michael Bueckert cited the unit’s role in mass surveillance of Palestinians in arguing that the relationship raises ethical concerns. “Tim Hortons must cut ties with this company immediately,” he said. Source
The founders’ military backgrounds do not, by themselves, establish military access to app data. The reporting does not demonstrate that Tim Hortons users’ information reached Israel’s military or was sold. Source Source Source
In 2022, Canadian privacy authorities found that the Tim Hortons app had collected extensive location data without adequate consent, according to the Anadolu report. That historical finding is not a new ruling on the Forter allegations. Source
Tim Hortons’ reported response doesn’t explain why fraud prevention needs ringtone and alarm names.
Comments