• Home
  • Technology
  • Gaming
  • Entertainment
  • World & Business
  • Science
  • Sports
  • AI
HomeTechnologyGamingEntertainmentWorld & BusinessScienceSportsAI
Technology

AI Challenges Coders and Artists on True Value of Creation

Engineers and artists debate whether message or execution defines value when AI handles technical work.

SM
MQ
MT
9 Sources, 25d ago, first seen 25d ago

TLDR

Musa Qureshi asked software engineers what they would do if AI becomes better at coding. Mike Three replied that artists opposing AI miss the point: value comes from the message and meaning, not process or product. Shaw added that art without communication or impact receives no attention. Justin agreed and noted the scarcity of strong conceptual collection ideas, comparing delegation to film direction. Anders stated AI is consuming the industry and anyone believing they code better than AI is delusional.

Combined views

285.9K

9 Sources, first seen 25d ago

17.5K likes776 comments363 saves1.6K reposts
Featured Source

Combined views

285.9K

9 Sources, first seen 25d ago

17.5K likes776 comments363 saves1.6K reposts
AI Challenges Coders and Artists on True Value of Creation

Sentiment

Positive33.9%66.1%Negative

Summary

Replies welcomed AI as a tool for strong conceptual art ideas and message-focused expression, while many others objected that it eliminates the joy of hands-on mastery, struggle, and creative growth through limitations.

Based on 145 sentiment-bearing replies from 115 accounts across 5 conversations.

Sentiment

Positive33.9%66.1%Negative

Summary

Replies welcomed AI as a tool for strong conceptual art ideas and message-focused expression, while many others objected that it eliminates the joy of hands-on mastery, struggle, and creative growth through limitations.

Based on 145 sentiment-bearing replies from 115 accounts across 5 conversations.

9 Sources

@shadmbrooks"AI art is trash slop and human made art is always superior!" Human made art⬇️
@_musaqureshiSoftware Engineers, what will you do if AI becomes better at coding than you?
@mikethreeartists who are anti-AI have completely lost sight of the fact that the process and the final image or product is not what makes something valuable it’s the content of the message and the meaning it communicates they’re vapid and self-important so they don’t understand what makes art valuable let alone what makes AI valuable to someone trying to communicate and create things that would otherwise take months or years alone without a team and infinite money they can create more with AI and reach more people and ultimately be a more effective artist or creator in terms of how successful they are with engaging an audience
@shawmakesmagicUse AI or don’t But if your art doesn’t say anything, doesn’t communicate or convey, doesn’t materially impact Nobody will give a fuck
@AndersReiche@_musaqureshi If you think you are better at coding than AI, you are delusional.
@RahllApparently calling an AI user a moron for quite literally copying and pasting another artist's work and claiming it as their own AI work makes ME the bad guy.
@justintrimbleThis is a good point. I see a shockingly low number of strong conceptual art collection ideas (about zero). Film directors don't do all the acting. There are levels to oversee. Map out what you want to convey and then delegate.
@RenattaI don’t get why people are anti-AI. AI is just a tool and it can be used for good or for bad. I think it’s because people don’t know much about it and are worried about what might come out if it. Reminds me of the late 90s when people were hesitant to use the internet.
@VorosTwinsBad art is better than AI. Bad art is better than AI. Bad art is better than AI. Bad art is better than AI. Bad art is better than AI. Bad art is better than AI. Bad art is better than AI.
    • HomeTechnologyGamingEntertainmentWorld & BusinessScienceSportsAI
    • Home
    • Technology
    • Gaming
    • Entertainment
    • World & Business
    • Science
    • Sports
    • AI

    9 Sources

    @shadmbrooks"AI art is trash slop and human made art is always superior!" Human made art⬇️
    @_musaqureshiSoftware Engineers, what will you do if AI becomes better at coding than you?
    @mikethreeartists who are anti-AI have completely lost sight of the fact that the process and the final image or product is not what makes something valuable it’s the content of the message and the meaning it communicates they’re vapid and self-important so they don’t understand what makes art valuable let alone what makes AI valuable to someone trying to communicate and create things that would otherwise take months or years alone without a team and infinite money they can create more with AI and reach more people and ultimately be a more effective artist or creator in terms of how successful they are with engaging an audience
    @shawmakesmagicUse AI or don’t But if your art doesn’t say anything, doesn’t communicate or convey, doesn’t materially impact Nobody will give a fuck
    @AndersReiche@_musaqureshi If you think you are better at coding than AI, you are delusional.
    @RahllApparently calling an AI user a moron for quite literally copying and pasting another artist's work and claiming it as their own AI work makes ME the bad guy.
    @justintrimbleThis is a good point. I see a shockingly low number of strong conceptual art collection ideas (about zero). Film directors don't do all the acting. There are levels to oversee. Map out what you want to convey and then delegate.
    @RenattaI don’t get why people are anti-AI. AI is just a tool and it can be used for good or for bad. I think it’s because people don’t know much about it and are worried about what might come out if it. Reminds me of the late 90s when people were hesitant to use the internet.
    @VorosTwinsBad art is better than AI. Bad art is better than AI. Bad art is better than AI. Bad art is better than AI. Bad art is better than AI. Bad art is better than AI. Bad art is better than AI.
    Today's Rank

    —

    Not ranked yet

    Today's Rank

    —

    Not ranked yet