Elon Musk accused Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelenskyy of lying about Starshield restrictions during a November 18 appearance at The New York Times’ DealBook Summit. The SpaceX CEO claimed Ukraine instead wanted to use the company’s consumer Starlink service for offensive military operations, according to The Verge. Source
Zelenskyy identified the restricted service as Starshield, according to Engadget. He said terminals using that service would lose their satellite connection when moving faster than 161 km/h, or 100 mph, along the entire front line and in Russian territory. That is a threshold for a terminal’s movement, not its download speed. Zelenskyy said the restrictions were helping Russian forces carry out more accurate strikes against Ukraine. Source
Musk described Starlink as a civilian system that was not intended for offensive drone strikes, arguing that those operations should use Starshield, which he described as a separate, US-government-controlled system. Source
“But do not ask me as a private individual to make kill decisions,” Musk said, as quoted by The Verge. Source
Interviewer Andrew Ross Sorkin pointed out that Zelenskyy had identified the restricted service as Starshield, not Starlink. When Sorkin asked whether Zelenskyy was not using Starshield or was lying, Musk replied: “He is lying.” He continued: “What he is actually saying is he wants to use Starlink for offensive military operations.” Source
Ukraine had already disputed an earlier allegation of Starlink misuse. Engadget, summarizing a CNBC report from late October, says a Ukrainian official argued that existing restrictions would have made it “physically impossible” to use Starlink for the strikes inside Russian territory that Musk had described. Source
Neither report provides technical records or contract terms establishing which service was restricted or what permissions governed the affected terminals. Source Source
Comments