/Tech3h ago

SpaceX IPO Branded Most Overhyped Of Decade, Retail Wealth Destruction Predicted

2461.5K233369202.9K
Original post
Lee Roach@leevalueroach

SpaceX is the most overhyped IPO of the decade and it will end exactly the way every overhyped IPO ends. Facebook IPO’d at $38 and traded under that for 15 months. Uber IPO’d at $45 and is still below that adjusted seven years later for a while. WeWork tried at $47 billion and ended at zero. Robinhood IPO’d at $38, hit $85, then $7. Coinbase IPO’d at $381 and was at $40 two years later. Rivian IPO’d at a $100 billion valuation with no meaningful revenue and gave back 90%. Beyond Meat. Peloton. Lyft. DoorDash. Bird. Each one a “generational company” the day it priced.

Each one a wealth destruction event for retail within 18 months. The pattern is not a coincidence. Hype IPOs are designed to transfer wealth from the people buying the story to the people who built the story. The bankers get paid. The early employees get out. The VCs get a markup they can show their LPs. The retail investor gets the bag. SpaceX is a great company. That has nothing to do with whether it’s a great stock at IPO. Greatness was already priced in five funding rounds ago. You are not getting in early. You are buying the exit. The only IPO worth chasing is the one nobody is talking about. Those don’t exist anymore because every IPO is marketed like a movie release. So the answer is: don’t chase. Wait two years. Buy it down 70% when the lockup unwinds and the narrative breaks. Or don’t buy it at all and put the money somewhere the bankers haven’t already extracted the alpha. Hype is not an asset class. It’s a tax.

8:10 AM · Jun 11, 2026 · 190.1K Views
Sentiment

Many users dismissed the SpaceX IPO as overhyped and likely to cause retail losses after warnings from Gary Marcus and critics, while others thanked the analysts or defended its long-term potential despite acknowledged short-term risks.

Pos
34.7%
Neg
65.3%
31 comments with sentiment.
Cluster Engagement
Posts from X
Most Activity
Most Activity
VIEWS8.5KBOOKMARKS9LIKES110RETWEETS23REPLIES12
Gary Marcus@GaryMarcus

For those about to invest in SpaceX,

1. Please don’t say you weren’t warned. You were. Many times, by many people. For many reasons.

2. Thousands of Elon’s thousands future great-grand children will thank you for your donations.

Lee Roach@leevalueroach

SpaceX is the most overhyped IPO of the decade and it will end exactly the way every overhyped IPO ends. Facebook IPO’d at $38 and traded under that for 15 months. Uber IPO’d at $45 and is still below that adjusted seven years later for a while. WeWork tried at $47 billion and ended at zero. Robinhood IPO’d at $38, hit $85, then $7. Coinbase IPO’d at $381 and was at $40 two years later. Rivian IPO’d at a $100 billion valuation with no meaningful revenue and gave back 90%. Beyond Meat. Peloton. Lyft. DoorDash. Bird. Each one a “generational company” the day it priced.

Each one a wealth destruction event for retail within 18 months. The pattern is not a coincidence. Hype IPOs are designed to transfer wealth from the people buying the story to the people who built the story. The bankers get paid. The early employees get out. The VCs get a markup they can show their LPs. The retail investor gets the bag. SpaceX is a great company. That has nothing to do with whether it’s a great stock at IPO. Greatness was already priced in five funding rounds ago. You are not getting in early. You are buying the exit. The only IPO worth chasing is the one nobody is talking about. Those don’t exist anymore because every IPO is marketed like a movie release. So the answer is: don’t chase. Wait two years. Buy it down 70% when the lockup unwinds and the narrative breaks. Or don’t buy it at all and put the money somewhere the bankers haven’t already extracted the alpha. Hype is not an asset class. It’s a tax.

3hViews 8.5KLikes 110Bookmarks 9
Gary Marcus@GaryMarcus

For those about to invest in SpaceX,

1. Please don’t say you weren’t warned. You were. Many times, by many people.

2. Thousands of Elon’s thousands future great-grand children will thank you for your donations.

Lee Roach@leevalueroach

SpaceX is the most overhyped IPO of the decade and it will end exactly the way every overhyped IPO ends. Facebook IPO’d at $38 and traded under that for 15 months. Uber IPO’d at $45 and is still below that adjusted seven years later for a while. WeWork tried at $47 billion and ended at zero. Robinhood IPO’d at $38, hit $85, then $7. Coinbase IPO’d at $381 and was at $40 two years later. Rivian IPO’d at a $100 billion valuation with no meaningful revenue and gave back 90%. Beyond Meat. Peloton. Lyft. DoorDash. Bird. Each one a “generational company” the day it priced.

Each one a wealth destruction event for retail within 18 months. The pattern is not a coincidence. Hype IPOs are designed to transfer wealth from the people buying the story to the people who built the story. The bankers get paid. The early employees get out. The VCs get a markup they can show their LPs. The retail investor gets the bag. SpaceX is a great company. That has nothing to do with whether it’s a great stock at IPO. Greatness was already priced in five funding rounds ago. You are not getting in early. You are buying the exit. The only IPO worth chasing is the one nobody is talking about. Those don’t exist anymore because every IPO is marketed like a movie release. So the answer is: don’t chase. Wait two years. Buy it down 70% when the lockup unwinds and the narrative breaks. Or don’t buy it at all and put the money somewhere the bankers haven’t already extracted the alpha. Hype is not an asset class. It’s a tax.

3hViews 1.2KLikes 9Bookmarks 2
Gary Marcus@GaryMarcus

here’s an entirely different reasons, and see also @edels0n’s thread.

Gary Marcus@GaryMarcus

Anyone considering investing in SpaceX should have a peek at this analysis from @andrewmccalip

https://andrewmccalip.com/space-datacenters

3hViews 3.2KLikes 9Bookmarks 1
Tony Greer@TgMacro

@leevalueroach Sir, THIS IS A CASINO.

6hViews 644Likes 10
Overlap by AP@ansujeet

Every example on that list was a business looking for a model.

SpaceX already has one.

Starlink: $11.4 billion revenue, $4.4 billion operating profit.

The difference between SpaceX and Rivian isn't the hype level.

It's that one had a profitable business before the IPO and one had a factory floor.

The "wait two years and buy down 70%" advice is correct for concept stocks.

For a company generating $4.4 billion in operating profit, the downside math is different.

Still expensive. Not the same risk category.

4hViews 661Likes 1
Hardwire Media@HardwireMedia

@leevalueroach Overhyped my fucking ass. Company like this comes along once a millennia.

6hViews 452Likes 13
Jack Rogers@jackrogers

@leevalueroach If it goes down significantly that would be an excellent opportunity to add to my IPO position. I’ll gladly buy on dips with a long term outlook. Let’s compare returns in 5 years.

5hViews 656Likes 7

@leevalueroach Yup but this dude is sending a rocket into orbit same day as the IPO and then one every 3-4 days for the rest of this month 🤣

4hViews 924Likes 6
Lee Roach@leevalueroach

@ElfoulyKarim Ok

4hViews 791Likes 6
Jake Dodge@JakeDodge17

Blah, blah, #84,621 of such warnings against the SpaceX IPO posted here on X. What is the point? Is Neville Singham in Shanghai paying posters to blunt the enthusiasm? Otherwise hard to understand why so many nervous Nancies feel the need to lecture from the same tedious talking points.

5hViews 321Likes 2
RG@RedsGaurav

@leevalueroach Found this on Twitter 😄

6hViews 114Likes 2Bookmarks 1

@leevalueroach What I can’t get my head around is off loading Microsoft, Meta, Google, Amazon, NVDA to buy this. Those companies will be worth much more in 5, hell even 3 years and actually make a metric ton of money. Strange times.

5hViews 274Likes 4

Although all of those that you mentioned popped at launch.

So buying it for a quick trade isn’t an awful idea

But yes, agree it was exit liquidity and long term a lot of those that didn’t do their homework will pay the price of the lesson

I think with this level of hype and they size with the forced buying from the indexes we will see a big pop.

So not black and white crazy everyone is piling in right now IMO

6hViews 400Likes 3
John Lynch@JohnPLynch0316

@leevalueroach How often to any of those companies launch rockets into space?

5hViews 324Likes 3

@leevalueroach Elon Musk will own a different class of shares that control 85% of the total voting power of SpaceX, that means all other investors in this company basically have no voting rights whatsoever. Imagine investing in a company that doesn’t answer to its investors. Thats SpaceX.

4hViews 82Likes 3
Lavender@Lavender_SVE

@leevalueroach I pre-ordered 2270 shares, but some friends have advised me to cancel my order in the past two days. I’ve always been someone who listens to advice. Besides, I’ve noticed that most IPOs perform poorly.

1hViews 497Likes 1

@leevalueroach None of those comps you mentioned shoot rockets into space so why do you use them to provide context to this IPO? The comp is meaningless.

4hViews 151Likes 2

@ElfoulyKarim @leevalueroach And? You don’t seem to comprehend how overvalued this IPO is. The cornerstone of his argument on why the stock will be worth it is idiotic nonsense on the level of HyperLoop. Data centres in spaaaaace is idiotic. Even at 100x cheaper $/kg lift, it is moronic.

2hViews 12
Not a NPC@SardonicMaster

@leevalueroach I mean or just maybe you are completely wrong. Maybe they continue to execute exactly what they say they are going to do and the stock is never below tomorrows trading ever again.... newsflash ... NOBODY KNOWS

5hViews 653
Pulsewhalewannabe@pulsewhalewana

@leevalueroach The concept of comparing the greatest founder led company to any of those may be the funniest thing I’ve read this morning.

5hViews 173Likes 1
Load more posts