Engadget’s Sam Rutherford gave the $1,099 Lenovo Googlebook 15 a 7.9/10 in his Oct. 30 review. Googlebooks are laptops running Google’s new Android-based operating system, Googlebook OS. Rutherford liked the Lenovo’s 15.3-inch, 120Hz OLED screen and its links to Android phones, but found its apps less versatile than software on similarly priced Windows and Mac laptops. In a separate Oct. 30 assessment, Engadget’s Nathan Ingraham called the $1,299 ASUS Googlebook 14 “a really lovely laptop” but questioned whether the operating system justified premium prices. He reported that the Acer Googlebook 14 started at $899 and was the only model below $1,000.
Phone perks, desktop compromises
Rutherford said pairing an Android phone with the Lenovo enabled file transfers, app casting and synced notifications. In his testing, transfers through the Files app were limited to files under 200MB, and casting felt stuttery. The Play Store offered mobile Photoshop rather than the full desktop version, he wrote, while some apps showed display glitches or could not fill the screen. He considered the laptop capable of general productivity but less versatile than similarly priced Windows or Mac alternatives.
Ingraham had a different mix of successes and frustrations. Android app casting worked reliably for him after setup, but shortcuts for continuing tasks from his phone sometimes failed to appear. His synced Chrome tab groups did not show up; an initial problem installing web apps was fixed by a later Chrome update. He found that the Android Slack app displayed one view at a time instead of the desktop version’s multiple columns, though Google apps and some third-party apps worked well.
A harsher account, with exceptions
In the transcript accompanying an Oct. 30 Just Josh upload, Just Josh said his team tried three of five Googlebooks. He praised the Lenovo’s build but reported trouble accessing a network file through Google’s Files app, a game that would not run on his Intel-based Lenovo and file-copying failures on that machine. His verdict was much harsher than Rutherford’s. One speaker in the same account said their XPS Googlebook was usable for after-hours writing with Google Suite, Notion and Canva. Another said every app they used worked, though Slack felt strange compared with a normal laptop.
Comments