Researcher Calls AI-Generated Vibe Reports Unsuitable for Peer Review
Reactions from ranked influencers
2 posts
Why am I thinking it's a vibe report? Because I do read those generated by coding agents every day. It's for your own reading and analysis, not for sharing with peer reviewers and the scientific community.
Yes https://x.com/fredahshi/status/2079887097486581782
I feel like I am writing human-authored meta-reviews to a lot of mostly-AI-reviewed papers, many of which were at least partially AI-written (with a lot of 100% AI scores on Pangram).😐 I don't know what the solution is, or even if it's a problem (other than feeling demoralizing) since AI can certainly help in research. But it feels like a conversation we should be having.