AI Excels in Math but Struggles With NeurIPS Reviews
Researchers discuss AI's inability to perform reliable NeurIPS paper reviews despite math and coding advances.
A Microsoft researcher tweeted that while AI drives major breakthroughs in mathematics and coding, it cannot yet perform proper NeurIPS reviews. A reply from an Inria research director noted that automating reviews requires reliable true/false verification mechanisms. The exchange highlights current limitations in using AI for scientific paper evaluation, where simple binary checks remain essential but challenging to implement reliably.
Combined views
3.4K
2 posts, first seen 3h ago
AI Excels in Math but Struggles With NeurIPS Reviews
Researchers discuss AI's inability to perform reliable NeurIPS paper reviews despite math and coding advances.
A Microsoft researcher tweeted that while AI drives major breakthroughs in mathematics and coding, it cannot yet perform proper NeurIPS reviews. A reply from an Inria research director noted that automating reviews requires reliable true/false verification mechanisms. The exchange highlights current limitations in using AI for scientific paper evaluation, where simple binary checks remain essential but challenging to implement reliably.
Reactions from ranked influencers
2 posts
Funny to think that AI can make major breakthroughs in Math and Coding but no it definitely can鈥檛 do a proper neurips review amiright?
@DimitrisPapail To automate things, a simple true/false verification is key