In her Sept. 16 review, Engadget’s Cherlynn Low gave the iPhone 18 Pro a 9/10 and called it “The standard setter.” She found its camera changes more compelling than its Siri AI performance. In a separate Oct. 29 column, Android Authority’s Dhruv Bhutani argued that Apple’s approach to AI appeals to him even though he considers Gemini more capable.
Camera controls with a caveat
Low highlighted the camera’s four user-selectable aperture settings: f/1.48, f/1.8, f/2.8 and f/4.0. Pairing aperture adjustments with shutter-speed controls gave her more versatility, she wrote. But in her testing, the difference between shots at f/1.48 and f/4.0 alone “isn’t very stark.” She called the phone’s camera setup the best among iPhones available at the time.
Engadget listed Siri AI’s beta status as a drawback. Low said she had to make repeated requests before it offered a broader variety of meal ideas. Siri did supply movie titles when Alexa+ failed to do so in her test, and Low said she had not yet conducted a dedicated Siri-versus-Gemini evaluation. She also noted that most Siri AI and iOS 27 updates would reach devices other than the iPhone 18 Pro.
Why one columnist prefers Apple’s approach
Bhutani’s argument is about choice rather than a claim that Siri outperforms Gemini. He prefers AI that remains more optional and favors local processing so personal data can stay on the phone when possible. He argues that some Apple Intelligence functions work without an internet connection, but says Siri AI’s capabilities are fairly limited offline. He also acknowledges Apple’s option to use cloud compute. For Bhutani, Gemini’s greater capabilities do not outweigh his preference for an AI approach that lets him rely less on remote processing.
Comments