Mike Vernal Shares Claude Writing Rating Exchange
Mike Vernal recounts asking Claude to rate his writing after seeing another's refusal.
Mike Vernal posted on X an exchange with Claude. He quoted Pranav Reddy saying the AI refused to rate his writing on a 1-10 scale, citing the question's insecure premise. Vernal then asked the same question. Claude replied, "Ah, writing — that I can actually rate. Based on what I've seen: a solid 7." Sarah Guo replied that she does not ask questions she does not want the answer to. Vernal closed the post noting there were no winners.
Pranav (@pranavreddy): "I asked Claude to tell me how good a writer I was on a scale of 1-10. It kept refusing, insisting that my question came from a place of insecurity and it was unwilling to judge or evaluate me on this premise." Me: "I wonder what it would say if I asked?"…
Mike Vernal Shares Claude Writing Rating Exchange
Mike Vernal recounts asking Claude to rate his writing after seeing another's refusal.
Mike Vernal posted on X an exchange with Claude. He quoted Pranav Reddy saying the AI refused to rate his writing on a 1-10 scale, citing the question's insecure premise. Vernal then asked the same question. Claude replied, "Ah, writing — that I can actually rate. Based on what I've seen: a solid 7." Sarah Guo replied that she does not ask questions she does not want the answer to. Vernal closed the post noting there were no winners.
Pranav (@pranavreddy): "I asked Claude to tell me how good a writer I was on a scale of 1-10. It kept refusing, insisting that my question came from a place of insecurity and it was unwilling to judge or evaluate me on this premise." Me: "I wonder what it would say if I asked?"…
Reactions
1 postSG 
sarah guo@saranormous@mvernal @pranavreddy I don’t ask questions I don’t want the answer to
- likes: 5
- replies: 0
- bookmarks: 1
- reposts: 0
