A study estimates that wind turbines killed 18.7 million bats in the United States between 1981 and 2024, according to New Scientist and Science. New Scientist reports that estimated annual deaths appear to have exceeded 1.5 million from 2021 onward. Science describes the toll as reaching 1.5 million annually by 2021. These are accounts of the same study, not separate estimates.
The researchers analyzed 499 reports from 277 wind facilities, focusing on 10 bat species, according to Science. New Scientist says the reports came from across the 48 adjoining states and that the model accounted for differences in carcass searches, turbines and their surroundings. The totals are modeled estimates, not a count of every bat killed. Science notes that monitoring methods vary and some company reports are not public. It also says the study cannot determine whether turbine deaths are causing bat population declines because bat numbers are difficult to estimate.
Changing when turbines run
Temporarily stopping turbines during periods of high bat activity, particularly in low winds, can substantially reduce fatalities with limited electricity loss, New Scientist reports. Science describes a separate analysis of 141 European wind farms that found avoiding operation in conditions favorable to bat flight can reduce deaths by more than 80%. That European finding is not a measured reduction at the US facilities in the mortality study.
Winifred Frick, chief scientist of Bat Conservation International, called the findings “shocking” and favored broader regulation, Science reports. A spokesperson for the American Clean Power Association acknowledged the risk to bats but questioned whether the analysis would change industry action or understanding.
Comments