Painted depictions of wealthy women became less curvaceous between 1650 and 1950, a new study reports, with no significant change in perceived body weight. A waist-to-hip ratio is not a bathroom scale. Source
Northumbria University’s Jeanne Bovet and her colleagues studied portraits painted by artists from England and France. Their findings appeared in Proceedings of the Royal Society B: Biological Sciences. According to Phys.org, more than 1,500 participants assessed 606 depictions of upper-class women in 486 paintings. It’s an affluent slice of society, not a group portrait of all European women. Source Source
What changed—and what didn’t
Participants worked in three groups on different tasks. These included matching painted figures to nine reference silhouettes representing different body weights and waist-to-hip ratios, rating how attractive the bodies appeared, and estimating age from faces. Source
Later depictions tended to have higher perceived waist-to-hip ratios: their waists appeared less pronounced relative to their hips. The trend remained after the researchers accounted for perceived age and weight, Phys.org reports. Perceived weight showed no significant change across the 300 years. Less hourglass did not necessarily mean slimmer. Source Source
In Science’s account, Bovet points to Laurent Pécheux’s 1765 portrait of Maria Luisa of Parma, with a perceived waist-to-hip ratio of 0.48, and Pierre-Paul-Léon Glaize’s Before the Mirror from 1873, with a perceived ratio of 0.72. Source
The wardrobe gets a vote, too
Clothing, padding, poses and artistic choices can all shape the image a viewer sees. Phys.org reports that the researchers deliberately focused on that representation, regardless of how it was produced. Source
The findings don’t establish that women’s actual bodies changed, or that everyone across Europe shared the same preferences. Modern participants’ assessments also aren’t direct testimony from the people who originally commissioned or viewed the paintings. Source Source
The researchers tentatively link the trend to broader social changes, including later marriage and declining fertility, Science reports. But Louis Boucherie, a University of Copenhagen computational social scientist who wasn’t involved in the study, cautions that a direct link between social change and beauty standards is hard to prove. Source
Comments