The National Academies of Sciences, Engineering, and Medicine wants journals to move faster on correcting or retracting unreliable research. It recommends completing most editorial reviews of concerns about a single paper within 12 weeks, with reviews rarely extending beyond six months, according to Nature and STAT. Source Source
Nature reported on Nov. 20 that the report’s planned Nov. 19 online publication had been delayed after Science journalists noted references containing fabricated author first names. A report about fixing the literature apparently needed a reference check of its own. Source
A review target, not an automatic retraction
The 12-week recommendation concerns the editorial review process—not a requirement to retract every paper that attracts a complaint. STAT describes the longer, six-month window as allowing for more complex cases. These are recommendations, not newly enacted rules. Source Source
“The big picture is, the process is too slow,” committee chair Randy Schekman, a cell biologist at the University of California, Berkeley, told Nature. He argued that faster, more transparent handling of concerns would strengthen the scientific record. Source
Nature reports, citing the Retraction Watch database, that retractions occur an average of around 2.4 years after publication. That measures publication-to-retraction time, not the time editors spend responding to a concern. Journals generally don’t disclose when they first learned of a problem, Nature says. Source
The report recommends disclosing those notification dates. It also calls for journals to look for problems proactively, potentially through journal-wide audits or regular monitoring of social media and platforms where researchers discuss published work. The proposed job goes beyond answering the complaint inbox faster. Source
Keep the data. Don’t assume fraud.
According to STAT, the report urges authors to retain original data. If concerns arise about a finding’s authenticity and those records can’t be produced, that could lead to retraction. Source
The report also calls for universities and other research institutions to respond more quickly and fully to research-integrity inquiries and make internal findings available to journals, funding organizations and the public. Funders should link grant awards to researchers and institutions agreeing to standards for conducting research and addressing errors, STAT reports. Source
Committee member Dorothy Bishop told Nature that retraction or correction must be distinguished from research misconduct. Honest mistakes need fixing, too. Editors shouldn’t wait for a university misconduct investigation before correcting a paper, she said. Source
Comments