Debate Questions if Symmetric Sticks Are Superior on Controllers

@wesleytypes posted a photo of a black Xbox controller and called it the best known to man. Replies compared it to PlayStation and other designs. Some users said Xbox controllers have been the best each generation and continued the Dreamcast approach. Others called the Xbox sticks uncomfortable and clicky or said the symmetric layout is inferior. One reply noted that many PC and Nintendo controllers copied the Xbox layout while Sony has not.