Samsung, SK hynix and Micron’s attempt to ditch a proposed RAM supply-collusion class action has failed. According to Hardware Busters, Judge Noël Wise of the U.S. District Court for the Northern District of California denied their joint motion to dismiss on November 14, 2026. Source
The ruling does not establish that the companies colluded. Hardware Busters reports that the judge assessed whether the complaint’s allegations, taken as true at this stage, described a plausible conspiracy—not whether the plaintiffs had proved one. Source
The case, Garciaguirre v. Samsung Electronics, was brought in June by 17 consumers and small businesses from five states, according to Hardware Busters. They seek to represent a class of indirect purchasers: buyers of products such as PCs, laptops and memory kits, rather than chips directly from manufacturers. Source
The companies say they followed the market
The plaintiffs accuse the companies of restricting conventional DRAM supply to drive up prices. The complaint also describes a production shift toward high-bandwidth memory, or HBM—the stacked DRAM mainly used in AI data centers rather than consumer systems, as VGC explains. That puts the dispute upstream of the memory kit in a PC shopping cart. Source Source
The companies’ explanation is considerably less conspiratorial: each was independently responding to falling prices and then growing AI demand, Hardware Busters reports. They also argued that the lawsuit repeated an earlier supply case whose dismissal was upheld in 2022. Source
VGC, citing Tom’s Hardware, reports that Wise answered the companies’ argument that competitors watch one another like hawks:
“Their contentions are more akin to hawks flying in formation — an activity that hawks ordinarily do not do.” Source
Why the case can proceed
According to Hardware Busters’ account of the ruling, the shift to HBM carried little weight by itself because HBM was more profitable when that shift began. Source
Instead, Hardware Busters reports that the judge considered additional alleged conduct, including:
- All three companies announcing DDR4 wind-downs between April and June 2025.
- Samsung and SK hynix refusing long-term conventional-DRAM supply agreements.
- Micron’s December 2025 decision to close its Crucial consumer brand.
- Restraint on new capacity and nearly identical customer-vetting questions adopted in January 2026. Source
Hardware Busters also reports that the court set aside the DDR3 allegations as not parallel, gave no weight to investor statements and declined to rely on industry conference meetings. Source
Hardware Busters reports that the companies must answer the complaint by December 7, with the first case management conference scheduled for January 12, 2027. That’s a litigation timetable, not a promise of cheaper RAM. Source
Comments