Pikmin 4’s paid Switch 2 upgrade is drawing harsh user reviews over its value, missing features and loading times. Nintendo Life reported a 2.3/10 Metacritic user score for Pikmin 4 – Nintendo Switch 2 Edition + Dandori Academy, compared with an 83/100 critic score. Source
According to Nintendo Life, the upgrade is available for £7.99 / $9.99 / €9.99, adding 4K visuals, the new Dandori Academy mode and voice commands to the 2023 game. More pixels, but no mouse controls or 60fps option. That’s not everyone’s preferred exchange rate. Source
One user quoted by Nintendo Life complained about reused Dandori Academy maps, while the outlet described frustration with paying for what some players perceived as a minor upgrade. Source
Getting out of a cave is the sticking point
Nintendo Life described a comparison by YouTuber Press A! in which exiting a cave took roughly six seconds in the original version and more than 30 seconds in the Switch 2 version. Source
Nintendo Life’s own test of the upgraded game found a shorter cave-exit wait of about 14–15 seconds, with entry taking about six seconds. Author Ollie Reynolds clarified in the comments that he was using a digital copy. Source
Why the cave-exit results differed is unclear. Still, extra time with a loading screen is a peculiar bonus feature for a paid upgrade. Source
The reviews have started their own argument
IGN described the backlash as “review bombing” in a social post; Nintendo Life used the same label in its report. Neither the post nor Nintendo Life’s report documents coordination. Source Source
In Nintendo Life’s comments, SBandy1 questioned the label, arguing that the complaints seemed legitimate. Reynolds argued that zero scores were a deliberate attempt to drag down the average. Source
Nintendo Life itself awarded the release 7/10 and still considered the upgrade price “probably appropriate” for the added content and visual enhancements. Source
Comments