Report
Thomas Nagel says a cockroach has interests—and Claude doesn’t
In WIRED, Thomas Nagel warns that chatbots’ convincing performances risk turning make-believe consciousness into real belief.
TLDR
Speaking to WIRED after winning the $1 million Berggruen Prize, Thomas Nagel rejects the idea that today’s chatbots are conscious. He argues that fluent language alone doesn’t establish an inner life and that consciousness likely requires something analogous to a nervous system. His welfare comparison is blunt: a cockroach has interests; Claude, in his view, does not.
Combined views
—
3 Sources, first seen ago

Comments