Reaction
Five of 14 ICLR 2027 submissions reportedly recommended for desk rejection
An ICLR 2027 area chair cites undefined jargon, poor results analysis and missing citations, without using LLM detectors.
TLDR
An ICLR 2027 area chair says they recommended desk rejection for five of 14 submissions over basic scientific-writing problems, including undefined jargon, results presented without analysis and claims lacking citations. They say they did not use LLM-detection tools and suggest using AI to flag such papers earlier, before they take up reviewers’ time.
Combined views
542
2 Sources, first seen ago
