/AI8h ago

Peter Wildeford and David Manheim dispute comparing existential AI risk to the satirical film Don't Look Up

Wildeford notes US AI regulation already outpaces the movie's government

3601167
Original post

@davidmanheim @So8res This seems clearly false. In "Don't Look Up" you could literally look up and see the asteroid coming, indisputably. Hence the title. We don't have such analagous ironclad indisputable evidence with AI, yet nonetheless the current US govt is doing more than the DLU govt did.

David Manheim@davidmanheim

@So8res It turns out "Don't look up" was too optimistic about how much humanity would even react to an existential threat.

10:12 AM 路 Jun 7, 2026 路 27 Views
Sentiment

Negative users object to the analyst's claim that AI lacks clear evidence of existential threat, arguing humanity is ignoring obvious warning signs.

Pos
0.0%
Neg
100.0%
1 comments with sentiment.
Cluster Engagement
Posts from X
Most Activity
Most Activity
VIEWS48LIKES2REPLIES1

@davidmanheim @So8res The math stuff is kinda a nerd thing and pales in attention/seriousness as the Mythos stuff, which people are very much responding to.

@davidmanheim @So8res This seems clearly false. In "Don't Look Up" you could literally look up and see the asteroid coming, indisputably. Hence the title. We don't have such analagous ironclad indisputable evidence with AI, yet nonetheless the current US govt is doing more than the DLU govt did.

8hViews 48Likes 2Bookmarks 0

@davidmanheim @So8res I don't understand what you're getting at. I agree the current public response is very clearly inadequate. I just think it's better than "Don't Look Up".

Talking about this movie confuses more than clarifies. It's a good movie but not a good analogy for where things are at.

David Manheim@davidmanheim

@peterwildeford @So8res I think there's a very real sense in which the vast majority of humanity is failing to see the incredibly real signs far past the point where it's reasonable. The public excuse in don't look up wasn't that there was no asteroid, it was that they had a plan about what to do.

7hViews 34Likes 1Bookmarks 0
David Manheim@davidmanheim

@peterwildeford @So8res I think there's a very real sense in which the vast majority of humanity is failing to see the incredibly real signs far past the point where it's reasonable. The public excuse in don't look up wasn't that there was no asteroid, it was that they had a plan about what to do.

8hViews 11