19h ago

Gary Marcus Accuses Geoffrey Hinton Of Fabricating AI Job Replacement Quotes

0
Original post

Dear @geoffreyhinton, You have to stop lying about me. First was the apparently faked quote on your web page that you couldn’t provide a source for (literally the only source I found was on your own webpage!). Then I just discovered that you told a Canadian Senate Committee that I said that AI “will only replace 2% of jobs” but so far I as know I never said such thing. Nothing on Google supports what you said. You again just made it up. And said it in a very serious forum. The closest I can find is in my “25 predictions for 2025,” written in 2024, where I *correctly* predicted that in *2025* “Less than 10% of the work force will be replaced by AI” . It was not all a prediction about what might happen years hence, and not close to the number you apparently fabricated. (And your testimony in any event came in 2026!) To the contrary, I have repeatedly said that AI *will* take a lot of jobs *eventually*, at least as far back as my December 2012 New Yorker essay called “Will a Robot Take Your Job?”. Please cut this deceitful behavior out. You are (repeatedly) trying to make me look bad by lying about things I said. That is not acceptable. Coming from a Nobel Prize winner it is downright reprehensible. No longer respectfully, Dr. Gary Marcus Professor Emeritus New York University

2:35 PM · May 16, 2026 View on X
Reposted by

Dear @geoffreyhinton,

You have to stop lying about me.

First was the apparently faked quote on your web page that you couldn’t provide a source for (literally the only source I found was on your own webpage!).

Then I just discovered that you told a Canadian Senate Committee that I said that AI “will only replace 2% of jobs” but so far I as know I never said such thing. Nothing on Google supports what you said. You again just made it up. And said it in a very serious forum. The closest I can find is in my “25 predictions for 2025,” written in 2024, where I *correctly* predicted that in *2025* “Less than 10% of the work force will be replaced by AI” . It was not all a prediction about what might happen years hence, and not close to the number you apparently fabricated. (And your testimony in any event came in 2026!)

To the contrary, I have repeatedly said that AI *will* take a lot of jobs *eventually*, at least as far back as my December 2012 New Yorker essay called “Will a Robot Take Your Job?”.

Please cut this deceitful behavior out. You are (repeatedly) trying to make me look bad by lying about things I said.

That is not acceptable. Coming from a Nobel Prize winner it is downright reprehensible.

No longer respectfully,

Dr. Gary Marcus Professor Emeritus New York University

9:35 PM · May 16, 2026 · 29.7K Views
Gary Marcus Accuses Geoffrey Hinton Of Fabricating AI Job Replacement Quotes · Digg