Report
ICLR area chair @yoavartzi says 41% of reviews in their pool received suspect-review notes
Area chair @yoavartzi reports several papers left with one review after ICLR added suspect-review notes.
TLDR
ICLR area chair @yoavartzi reports suspect-review notes on 41% of reviews for live papers in their pool, with quite a few papers left with one review. Separately, @shiqiang_w suggests that assignments outside reviewers’ expertise may encourage AI use, citing their own review batch and others’ accounts.
Combined views
4K
3 Sources, first seen ago
Comments