10h ago

CEO Calls AI Art Criticism Cultural Essentialism

0
Original post

These judgments are a solid example of cultural essentialism. iow, the belief that there is a fixed essence of "real cinema" or "true art" Every generation internalizes the standards of its artistic community and then experiences those standards as self evidently correct rather than socially learned. Basically: - A group of people/artists develops certain conventions, eg: "good films have three act structures","cinema should be shot on film", "art should be representational", "animation should only be done with certain software" . often as a way of rebelling against the prevailing system - These conventions prove useful in some contexts - Over time, people forget that they were choices made by particular humans in particular historical circumstances Opinions are not facts. Don’t mistake accumulated traditions and conventions for laws of nature

4:50 AM · May 30, 2026 View on X
Cristóbal ValenzuelaCristóbal Valenzuela@c_valenzuelab

These judgments are a solid example of cultural essentialism. iow, the belief that there is a fixed essence of "real cinema" or "true art" Every generation internalizes the standards of its artistic community and then experiences those standards as self evidently correct rather than socially learned. Basically: - A group of people/artists develops certain conventions, eg: "good films have three act structures","cinema should be shot on film", "art should be representational", "animation should only be done with certain software" . often as a way of rebelling against the prevailing system - These conventions prove useful in some contexts - Over time, people forget that they were choices made by particular humans in particular historical circumstances Opinions are not facts. Don’t mistake accumulated traditions and conventions for laws of nature

11:50 AM · May 30, 2026 · 12.3K Views
7:06 PM · May 30, 2026 · 4.5K Views