• Home
  • Technology
  • Gaming
  • Entertainment
  • World & Business
  • Science
  • Sports
  • AI
HomeTechnologyGamingEntertainmentWorld & BusinessScienceSportsAI
    • Home
    • Technology
    • Gaming
    • Entertainment
    • World & Business
    • Science
    • Sports
    • AI
    AI

    Criticism of AI safety's perceived ties to the left

    One commenter argues that much of the AI safety movement tied itself too closely to Democrats. Another calls the partisan alignment of effective altruists and accelerationists bad for America's tech advantage.

    roonRO
    typedfemaleTY
    Richard NgoRN
    8 Sources, ,

    TLDR

    The criticism centers on political influence and neutrality. One commenter alleges that effective altruists generally, and Amodei specifically, pushed AI safety leftward for short-term power while obstructing attempts to stay politically neutral. That concern overlaps with another commenter's argument that much of the movement made the wrong political bet by attaching itself too closely to Democrats.

    A separate commenter criticizes the partisan split itself, calling effective altruists' alignment with Democrats and accelerationists' alignment with Republicans “probably bad for America” and “certainly bad for our tech advantage.”

    Combined views

    208.8K

    8 Sources, first seen 23d ago

    Combined views

    208.8K

    8 Sources, first seen 23d ago

    2.7K likes
    23d ago
    first seen 23d ago
    2.7K likes
    234 comments
    301 saves
    92 reposts
    234 comments
    301 saves
    92 reposts

    Sentiment

    Positive——Negative

    Summary

    Not enough discussion yet.

    No sentiment analysis available yet.

    Sentiment

    Positive——Negative

    Summary

    Not enough discussion yet.

    No sentiment analysis available yet.

    Today's Rank

    —

    Not ranked yet

    Today's Rank

    —

    Not ranked yet

    8 Sources

    Eliezer Yudkowsky@allTheYudI note, because I think that even now it still matters: On my history, EAs generally and Amodei specifically, indulged in politically polarizing "AI safety" in a leftist direction, because that got them short-term power; stymieing others' attempts to stay right-left neutral.23d
    roon@tszzlI think if you really cared about ai safety you should go back in time a couple years and be a credible maga republican23d
    Tanishq Mathew Abraham, Ph.D.@iScienceLuvr@tszzl a big part of the ai safety movement just made the wrong bet politically and attached themselves too closely to the democrats23d
    Richard Ngo@RichardMCNgoRT @allTheYud: I note, because I think that even now it still matters: On my history, EAs generally and Amodei specifically, indulged in po…23d
    Pedro A. Ortega@AdaptiveAgentsBack before Covid, I used to jokingly refer to the "we'll build a godlike AI, keep control of it concentrated, manage human flourishing, and call that safety" crowd as "the little Stalins" 😃23d
    Zak Kukoff@zckIt’s probably bad for America - and certainly bad for our tech advantage - that effective altruists and accelerationists have so neatly mapped to Dem/Republican23d
    typedfemale@typedfemaleanthropic can halt the polarization of ai safety by building more data centers in a way that maximizes the suffering of rural swing state farmers22d

    8 Sources

    Eliezer Yudkowsky@allTheYudI note, because I think that even now it still matters: On my history, EAs generally and Amodei specifically, indulged in politically polarizing "AI safety" in a leftist direction, because that got them short-term power; stymieing others' attempts to stay right-left neutral.23d
    roon@tszzlI think if you really cared about ai safety you should go back in time a couple years and be a credible maga republican23d
    Tanishq Mathew Abraham, Ph.D.@iScienceLuvr@tszzl a big part of the ai safety movement just made the wrong bet politically and attached themselves too closely to the democrats23d
    Richard Ngo@RichardMCNgoRT @allTheYud: I note, because I think that even now it still matters: On my history, EAs generally and Amodei specifically, indulged in po…23d
    Pedro A. Ortega@AdaptiveAgentsBack before Covid, I used to jokingly refer to the "we'll build a godlike AI, keep control of it concentrated, manage human flourishing, and call that safety" crowd as "the little Stalins" 😃23d
    Zak Kukoff@zckIt’s probably bad for America - and certainly bad for our tech advantage - that effective altruists and accelerationists have so neatly mapped to Dem/Republican23d
    typedfemale@typedfemaleanthropic can halt the polarization of ai safety by building more data centers in a way that maximizes the suffering of rural swing state farmers22d