Proposal to let ICML, ICLR and NeurIPS area chairs desk-reject roughly half their assigned papers
An area chair says they can quickly spot papers with virtually no chance of acceptance before review.
TLDR
An area chair proposed letting chairs desk-reject roughly 50% of their assigned papers at ICML, ICLR and NeurIPS. They argued that a quick scan could identify papers they see as having almost no chance of acceptance, sparing reviewers the work. In a later post, the chair said the idea might be less controversial than they first thought and claimed there are now more low-quality papers than before.
Combined views
—
1 Source, first seen ago