1up.com — 1UP praises The Legend of Zelda: Twilight Princess with a perfect score - better than any PS3 game reviewed by them. Is Twilight Princess even better than Ocarina of Time? It certainly seems so, as the game is maintaining an over 9.8 rating on Game Rankings as well.
Nov 17, 2006 View in Crawl 4
muncherNov 17, 2006
No, it can't be "better" than Ocarina of Time. There's nothing better than perfect.
kiregotiNov 17, 2006
Twilight Princess is cel shaded. No joke. Or, at least, the character models are. It's actually running on a modified Wind Waker engine. The only difference is that the aesthetic objectives this time around were very different. Surprised?
telapanNov 17, 2006
'Wii = Zelda = 10360 = Gears = 10PS3 = Resistance = 8.5'GameCube = Zelda = 10360 = Gears = 10PS3 = Resistance = 8.5Does this sum things up too? I think not. My point is that this game has been in the making for many years and is still coming out for the Gamecube. This doesn't seem like a ligitimate reason to buy a Wii.
Closed AccountNov 17, 2006
zelda is the law.a link to the past anyone?
mattiptonNov 17, 2006
I loved Majora's Mask but there were definately some problems with confusion for me. I remember I'd run out of time like on the first time through a series of events and then on the second time through I'd go off journeying blindly back to where I ran out of time... only to find out that I didn't need to redo certain stuff... or that I had wasted time stopping along the way second guessing about what things I'd have have to redo... but at the same time if I didn't second guess then I might potentially waste even more time back tracking if the events were indeed different the second time through. This got better at the game progressed due to new abilities... but man it always made me wish there was an event tracking log that appeared after a the first time through a certain area where the game shows you required events for at the main story. So you could realize what isn't required second time around... it didn't seem fair when things were just changed up the second time through. Same thing with items to some extent... but not as bad. If you always checked your inventory after running out of time then no problem... but I also remember making bad assumptions with items or just plain forgetting about to check inventory as well... especially with items that were traded.
amazingandrexNov 17, 2006
Or better yet, go into your profile and uncheck "Gaming News".
etheoNov 17, 2006
Honestly, I dont' think any game SHOULD entitle a perfect 10 score. Mainly because there's really no such thing as perfect. Don't get me wrong though, as much as I want Zelda to be a 10/10, I think that just detract its credibility. I mean, I had my doubts when 1UP gave Gears a 10/10... it just makes those jaded ones shouting out "bias"
thomasjayNov 18, 2006
Is it even fair to include GoW in that comparison? It's hardly a launch title.