techcrunch.com — By now it seems like just about everyone has seen the iPhone 4 vs. HTC EVO video (and the rebuttal video). The video portrays an electronics store employee trying to convince a person looking for an iPhone 4 to buy an HTC EVO 4G instead. Its hilarious like all good humor, so funny because its at least partially true. But you know who didnt find it funny? Best Buy. How do I know that? Because theyre trying to fire the kid who made it.
The video in question was made by Brian Maupin, a 25-year-old based in Kansas City, Missouri. For the past three and a half years hes been working at Best Buy selling mobile phones. Hes probably not going to be doing that anymore as Best Buy has suspended him indefinitely and is currently taking the steps to terminate him, Maupin tells us. The reason? The video.
The video became so popular (it currentlyhas nearly 1.3 million views on YouTube) that someone at Best Buy corporate saw it. They then put two-and-two together that it was an employee at one of their stores that made it, and the hammer came down. They felt it disparaged a brand they carried (iPhone/Apple) as well as the store itself and were fearful of stockholders & customers being turned off to Best Buy Mobile, Maupin says.
Whats ridiculous is that nowhere in the video does Maupin have anything indicating thefictitiousstore the iPhone buyer is walking into is a Best Buy. At the beginning, the cartoon employeeidentifiesthe store as Phone Mart. The character isnt even wearing the signature Best Buy blue polo shirt and theyre standing in an outdoor field with a pink tree.
In other words, nothing about this video seems to imply Best Buy in anyway.In fact, the only reason it will be tied to Best Buy now is thanks to this story.
Maupin says he was asked to quit, which he declined to do, and so they suspended him this morning telling him that he would most likely be terminated after they review it with HR. He expects the decision in the next day or two. I issued a statement to them explaining that the video was intended to be comedic and hence, not taken seriously by them or all these stockholders & customers they are worried about [being] turned off to buying from them due to the video, Maupin says in his defense.
Maupin isnt sure how exactly Best Buy corporate knew to tie the video to him, but believes they did so because a couple other videos under his Tiny Watch Productions (a little indie film group he made with his friends) YouTube account featured videos referencing him and Best Buy. Maupin says he removed those videos at Best Buys request, but refuses to take down the EVO vs. iPhone videos because, again, they in no way reference Best Buy.
Regardless of if he keeps his job or not (which he doesnt expect to), Maupin is optimistic. I see it all as a blessing in disguise. Ive wanted to start my career in graphic design/animation for so long, I see this as my kick in the pants to go get it, he says.
And now, for an encore:
CrunchBase InformationHTC EVO 4GiPhone 4Best BuyInformation provided by CrunchBase
Jul 1, 2010 View in Crawl 4
gk128Jul 1, 2010
I'm an iPhone owner and a fan, but even I still find this video funny.
There is blind fanboy-ism out there, and this is a funny example of it.
christophercJul 1, 2010
Best Buy can't take a joke... and it wasn't even at their expense. Get that iPhone 4 out of your ass!
therednewtJul 2, 2010
Seriously. It's not as if this guy identified himself in anyway with Best Buy in the videos or when he posted the video. I had no idea he worked for Best Buy until I saw this story. Just plain dumb.
greengooJul 1, 2010
I'm a happy Verizon customer, but I have mad EVO envy. Picking up my Droid X in two weeks, hopefully it's as good as they say, even if it's no EVO.
sengbeJul 1, 2010
The only reason anyone will connect this guy to Best Buy is because they are making such a big issue about it. Their stock price should take a hit due to their boneheaded response.
finalbroadcastJul 1, 2010
This is funny, but he could have picked a phone that didn't require more batteries than a Prius. But Best Buy, get a sense of humor.
sal4Jul 1, 2010
It's a funny video :) Hope it's not meant seriously though, cause then the guy is really missing the point... it's software what makes the iPhone great, not hardware. That the iPhone 4's hardware is kick-ass too is just a bonus ;)Comment is buried, click here to see the rest.
divicJul 2, 2010
Seems illegal that Best Buy fire this kid over the making of a video that doesnt even make a hint at Best Buy.
mrmann14Jul 2, 2010
But it is funny...
I don't care.
But it doesn't mention Best Buy in any way.
I don't care.
But this will only cause more bad publicity your Best Buy...
I don't care.
Well then f*ck you and f*ck your company.
wasternJul 2, 2010
The EVO guy was as big a fanboy as the iPhone person. There were counter points for most of the arguments made by him beyond "I don't care".
Still stupid he was fired.
khsheehanJul 2, 2010
Come on Best Buy, lighten up. Just let employees with an opinion speak there mind (especially in this type of situation where it's all for the sake of humor).
therednewtJul 2, 2010
It baffles me that this would be a problem unless he somehow linked himself to Best Buy. Otherwise, their complaint is moot.
bearpaw88Jul 2, 2010
It's okay...at least the employee in question got to overclock his EVO processor from 1 jiggahertz to 1.2 jiggahertz...
dstoryJul 2, 2010
Yet one more reason why Best Buy Sucks.
dgen_xJul 2, 2010
After watching the video I had no idea the person who created it had even SHOPPED in a best buy...let alone sold mobile phones for bb.
With this story I now know that he once worked for bb...and I will continue to NOT shop best buy because of their stupidity.
Who am I kidding...there isn't much that could have gotten me to walk back into a best buy!
amateurxJul 2, 2010
Over time I forget why I don't shop at Best Buy. Then I remember; it's stories like this that remind me.
sappassJul 2, 2010
This is not cool. The kid didn't ID Best Buy in any way. If it hadn't been for them, I never would have known. He should sue them if he gets fired over freedom of speech, I'm pretty sure he would win
xromanJul 2, 2010
That sucks, another reason why I'll never go to Best Buy.
kidviciousJul 2, 2010
I don't understand... Did he make the video on company time? Did he identify himself or the video as a representative of best buy? This s**t has wrongful termination written all over it.
arthereSep 27, 2010
That video is hilarious, I can't believe he's gonna lose his job over it.
http://www.creditcardassociate.com/best-buy.html